The hype
Guests love the 'Old World' charm and the steakhouse, but the breakfast situation is a chaotic free-for-all on weekends.
Madison
$170-250 / nótt
Pantaðu þetta ef You want a grand, historic wedding venue vibe with a steakhouse attached, and you don't mind the occasional train rumble.
Af hverju fólk elskar þetta
- The Conservatory: a stunning glass atrium that makes you feel like you're in a Victorian greenhouse
- Rod's Steak & Seafood Grille: dining inside restored 1890s Pullman railway cars is a legitimate bucket-list experience
- Convenience: literally steps from the Convent Station NJ Transit stop for a direct shot to NYC
Stutt samantekt: It’s a wedding factory first and a hotel second—expect bridal parties in the lobby and a fight for a bagel at the free breakfast.
Farið yfir af @whereismayling: I stayed here for a wedding and the conservatory is just magical. The room was super cozy, and I actually loved the bathroom lighting for getting ready. Definitely grab a spot by the fireplace if you can!
Gestur sem dvaldi hér sagði
Reality check
The 2023 renovation modernized the rooms, but some long-time guests hate the new 'dark and moody' ballroom decor compared to the old white-and-gold style.
- You love history and want to dine in a vintage train car without leaving your hotel
- You are attending a wedding on-site (it's the ultimate stumble-home convenience)
- You need easy train access to NYC but want to sleep in the suburbs
Hreinlæti og viðhald
8.5
- Housekeeping: Generally reliable daily service, though recent reviews mention missed dust in corners post-renovation.
- Bathroom hygiene: Bathrooms are newly renovated (2023) and mostly sparkling, with good water pressure.
- Maintenance: Solid condition thanks to the 2023 overhaul; no peeling paint or leaky faucets reported recently.
- Linens & towels: Crisp and new following the renovation; towels are standard hotel grade.
- Odors & scents: Lobby smells fresh; hallways can smell like food during wedding dinner service.
Sleepability™
6MIÐLUNGS
0-4HÁTT
4-7.5MIÐLUNGS
7.5-10ÞÖGULT
- NJ Transit trains passing directly behind the hotel
- Wedding after-parties spilling into the hallways on weekends
Áður en þú bókar
Gott að vita
- There is a 'Utility Fee' of ~$28.67/night added to your bill—essentially a resort fee for wifi and parking.
- Breakfast is free but the seating area is tiny; grab your bagel and take it back to your room.
- Check-in is at 4:00 PM, which is tight for 5:00 PM weddings—request early check-in well in advance.
Hvað á að pakka
- Earplugs (essential for train-side rooms)
- A dressy outfit for dinner at Rod's (it feels wrong to eat there in sweatpants)
- A portable steamer (hotel irons are hit-or-miss according to reviews)
Herbergis-Genie
Bestu val
- Classic King on the 'front' side (facing away from the tracks) for better sleep
- Junior Suites for a bit more breathing room if you're getting ready for an event
Herbergi til að forðast
- Any room facing the rear/train tracks if you are a light sleeper
- Rooms near the elevator banks on weekends due to late-night foot traffic
Herbergisbeiðna-Genie – afrita og líma
“I am a light sleeper and would like to request a room on the front side of the building, facing away from the NJ Transit train tracks. A top-floor assignment would also be appreciated to minimize foot traffic noise.”
Algengar spurningar og falin ábendingar
Allt sem þú vilt vita áður en þú bókar.
Is there really a pool?
No. The 'glass atrium' you see in photos is the Conservatory, a wedding venue. There is no pool.
How bad is the train noise?
It's real. The tracks are right there. If you are sensitive, you absolutely need a front-facing room.
Is breakfast included?
Yes, a deluxe continental buffet is included, but expect a crowd and limited seating on weekends.
Can I bring my dog?
Yes, it is pet-friendly with a $50/day fee. Dogs only.
Is there a gym?
Yes, there is a 24-hour fitness center called 'Active Life Studio' on-site.
How do I get to NYC?
Walk to the Convent Station platform (literally on the property edge) and take the NJ Transit Morris & Essex line direct to Penn Station (~60 mins).
Innherja ábendingar
- ✨
The 'Parlour Cars' at Rod's aren't just for show—you can actually book a table inside them for a regular dinner.
- ✨
The 'Utility Fee' includes a $20 food credit for the hotel restaurant—make sure you use it or you lose it!
- ✨
If the main hotel bar is packed with wedding guests, sneak over to GK's Red Dog Tavern for a more chill local vibe.
5 hlutir sem þú ættir að vita áður en þú ferð
💡The 'indoor pool' listed on some travel sites is a myth; it's a wedding venue.
💡The 2023 renovation replaced the classic white/gold ballroom with a dark, moody blue theme that some brides are furious about.
💡You can hear the train announcements from the platform if your window is open on the back side.
💡The 'free' breakfast often runs out of the good bagels by 9:00 AM on Sundays.
💡There is a specific 'bed bug report' from July 2024/2025 online—check your mattress corners with a flashlight before unpacking.
Staðbundin handbók
Kort
Sjáðu hvar Madison er staðsett og hvað er nálægt.