The hype
Guests love the tropical grounds and pool area but consistently note the rooms feel tired and worn.
Humphrey's Half Moon Inn
$150-250/ notte
Prenota se You want a tropical 'Hawaii-lite' escape with a killer on-site concert venue and marina views.
Perché piace così tanto
- Lush, jungle-like grounds that feel like a Polynesian hideaway
- Direct access to Humphrey's Concerts by the Bay (watch from your balcony if lucky)
- Walkable waterfront path along Shelter Island
In sintesi: A charmingly dated tiki time capsule where the concert lineup matters more than the threadbare carpets.
Recensito da @wine.and.dine.with.irene: We booked this for our anniversary and NYE, and it was magic. The suite had a killer view of the marina, and the food was honestly some of the best we've had. It’s rare to find a spot that feels this fancy but is still so fun for our boys.
Cosa hanno detto gli ospiti che hanno soggiornato qui
Reality check
The 'Garden View' often means 'Palm Tree & Bird Poop View' with little privacy on ground floors.
- You have tickets to a show at Humphrey's Concerts by the Bay
- You love a retro, kitschy tiki vibe over modern minimalism
- You want a resort feel without the mega-resort price tag
Pulizia e manutenzione
7.8
- Housekeeping: Hit or miss. Some guests report missed days or having to request service multiple times.
- Bathroom hygiene: Generally clean surfaces, but expect older grout, chipped tubs, and low water pressure.
- Maintenance: The property is showing its age. Peeling paint and worn carpets are common complaints.
- Linens & towels: Functional but not luxurious. Towels can feel a bit scratchy and thin.
- Odors & scents: Older rooms often have a lingering musty or damp smell due to the marina location.
Sleepability™
7MODERATO
0-4RUMOROSO
4-7.5MODERATO
7.5-10SILENZIOSO
- Live concert audio (May-Oct)
- Navy jets from nearby NAS North Island
- Loud in-room air conditioning units
Prima di prenotare
Buono a sapersi
- Resort fee is ~$20/night and includes bike rentals and spotty wifi
- Parking is $25/night for self-parking
- There are no elevators to second-floor rooms — pack light or ask for ground floor
Cosa portare
- Earplugs (for the jets and concerts)
- Sandals (for the pool and walking to Bali Hai)
- A mobile hotspot (if you absolutely need internet)
Genio delle camere
Migliori scelte
- Upper-level Marina View rooms (vaulted ceilings, quieter, better views)
- Suites (significantly more spacious, good for families)
Camere da evitare
- Ground floor Poolside rooms (zero privacy, noise from pool bar)
- Rooms directly facing the concert venue (unless you want the free show and noise)
Genio delle richieste camera – copia e incolla
“I would love to request an upper-level room with a Marina View to avoid foot traffic noise. If possible, please avoid the ground floor units near the pool.”
FAQ e consigli nascosti
Tutto ciò che vuoi davvero sapere prima di prenotare.
Is the pool heated?
Yes, the large outdoor pool is heated and open year-round.
Can I see the concerts from my room?
Only specific Marina/Bay view rooms have a direct line of sight, and they book up fast. Most others just get the audio.
Is breakfast included?
No, breakfast is à la carte at Humphrey's SoCAL Dining, though some packages include it.
How far is the beach?
There is no swimming beach on property (it's a marina). Ocean Beach is about a 10-15 minute drive.
Is it walkable to downtown?
No, Shelter Island is isolated. You need a car or Uber to get to Gaslamp or Old Town (approx. 15-20 mins).
Are there fridges in the rooms?
Yes, all rooms have microwaves and mini-fridges.
Suggerimenti degli Insider
- ✨
Walk 5 minutes to Bali Hai for their famous (and lethal) Mai Tais — stronger than anything at the hotel bar.
- ✨
The 'Half Moon Pass' includes 1-hour bike rentals; use them to ride the flat, scenic path along Shelter Island.
- ✨
If you don't have concert tickets, you can often rent a kayak or dinghy to listen from the water in the marina.
5 cose da sapere prima di partire
💡The 'tropical' birds on property are beautiful but loud at sunrise.
💡The carpet in hallways and some rooms feels decades old and can smell musty.
💡Housekeeping can be inconsistent; some guests report having to beg for fresh towels.
💡The in-room safes are tiny (often too small for a 15-inch laptop).
💡You might spot famous musicians hanging out at the Backstage Live lounge after their set.
Guida locale
Mappa
Scopri dove si trova Humphrey's Half Moon Inn e cosa c'è nelle vicinanze.