The hype
Travelers rave about the 'immaculate' cleanliness and 'Long Island Zen' vibe, but often wish for better sound insulation.
The Shoals Suites & Slips
$159-293/ night
Book this if You want a stylish, low-key 'boatel' base for North Fork wine tasting where you can eat oysters at 2am.
Why People Love It
- The 'Oyster Automat' vending machine dispensing fresh oysters 24/7
- Scandi-nautical design that feels like a wealthy friend's guest house
- Direct marina access with boat slips for arriving by sea
Quick Take: A gorgeous, glorified motel renovation that nails the aesthetic but lacks the soundproofing and amenities (pool, gym) of a full resort.
Reviewed by @morgany.eats: I felt my stress melt away the second I unlocked my suite. Sipping wine on the patio while watching the boats drift by was magic. It’s the perfect spot to grab fresh seafood nearby and just disconnect. Truly a hidden gem on the North Fork.
Guest Who Stayed Here Said
Reality check
The 'kitchenette' is handy but lacks a freezer, so don't bring ice cream.
- You love oysters enough to buy them from a vending machine
- You prefer a quiet, independent stay over a full-service resort
- You are arriving by boat or want to charter one easily
Cleanliness & Maintenance
9.5
- Housekeeping: Daily service upon request; consistently praised as 'immaculate'.
- Bathroom hygiene: Sparkling; modern tile and grout are kept in top condition.
- Maintenance: Newly renovated feel, though soundproofing is a structural weak point.
- Linens & towels: High-quality Frette linens and fluffy towels.
- Odors & scents: Fresh, salty sea air; no musty or chemical smells reported.
Sleepability™
7.5SILENT
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
- Footsteps from upper-floor guests
- Mechanical equipment cycling on/off near Suite 1
- Thin walls between connecting rooms
Before you book
Good to know
- The 'Little Ram' food truck is seasonal (weekends/Wednesdays, May-Labor Day).
- There is a $25/night resort fee that covers bikes, beach passes, and breakfast.
- Strict no-pets policy.
What to pack
- White noise machine (to drown out thin-wall noise)
- Oyster shucking knife (for the vending machine haul)
- Cooler with ice (since the mini-fridges lack freezers)
Room Genie
Best picks
- Grand Suites (set further back, more privacy)
- Upper floor rooms (for balconies and no overhead foot traffic)
Rooms to avoid
- Suite 1 (ground floor) - cited for loud mechanical noise cycling all night
- Ground floor rooms if you hate hearing footsteps above you
Room Request Genie – copy & paste
“I'd love to request an upper-floor suite to avoid overhead noise. Please ensure I am NOT placed in Suite 1 or any room adjacent to the mechanical equipment.”
FAQ & Hidden tips
Everything you actually want to know before you book.
Is there a pool?
No. There is beach access nearby, but absolutely no pool on the property.
Can I arrive by boat?
Yes, there are 20 slips available. You need to reserve one in advance.
Is breakfast included?
Yes, a continental breakfast (bagels, yogurt, coffee) is included in the resort fee.
Is it open year-round?
Yes, but amenities like the food truck and outdoor events are seasonal (May-Sept).
Is there a gym?
No fitness center on-site.
How far is the beach?
You are on the water (marina), but swimming beaches like Cedar Beach are a short drive or bike ride away.
Insider Tips
- ✨
The 'Oyster Automat' outside is open 24/7—perfect for a late-night snack.
- ✨
Use the free hotel bikes to ride to 'The Old Field Vineyards' nearby.
- ✨
Wednesday nights in summer often feature an 'Oyster Happy Hour' at the food truck.
5 things to know before you go
💡The 'kitchenette' fridges have no freezer compartment.
💡You can hear your neighbors' conversations through the walls.
💡The 'coffee shop' is really just a counter in the lobby.
💡There is a vending machine that sells fresh oysters and 'Bang Bang' sauce 24/7.
💡Ground floor patios offer zero privacy from people walking by.
Local Playbook
Map
See where The Shoals Suites & Slips is located and what's nearby.