The hype
A beautiful, quiet retreat with fantastic pools and grounds, but the service and housekeeping can sometimes feel stretched thin.
Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton
$400-$800/ nacht
Boek dit als You want historic 'old money' luxury and the largest private beach in Key West, away from the chaotic Duval Street party scene.
Waarom mensen ervan houden
- Largest private beach in Key West (1,100 feet)
- Two oceanfront pools (one adults-only, one family)
- Stunning 1920s architecture recently renovated in 2023-2024
Snel Overzicht: It's a gorgeous historic property with a massive private beach, but expect a hefty resort fee, pricey parking, and a beach that often has more seaweed than swimmable water.
Beoordeeld door @celebratetheweekend: My holiday stay at Casa Marina was the perfect winter escape. I loved lounging by the pool and watching the herons on the beach. The golden sunsets were stunning, and walking past the illuminated sand Christmas tree at night felt incredibly magical.
Gast die hier verbleef zei
Reality check
The recent renovations are stunning, but you're paying luxury prices for a beach that isn't pristine Caribbean quality.
- You prefer a quiet, resort-style vacation over the loud Duval Street nightlife
- You want direct beach access and oceanfront pools
- You appreciate historic architecture mixed with modern luxury
Schoonmaak & Onderhoud
7
- Housekeeping: Hit or miss. Many report spotless, newly renovated rooms, while others complain about stretched-thin housekeeping and sandy floors.
- Bathroom hygiene: Post-renovation bathrooms are beautiful and clean, but older reviews noted slow drains and worn grout.
- Maintenance: Much improved since the 2023-2024 renovations, though some guests still report minor issues like slow-draining sinks or AC quirks.
- Linens & towels: Generally fresh and high-quality, though a few guests mentioned having to request fresh towels when housekeeping skipped a day.
- Odors & scents: The lobby smells like a signature citrus scent, but some older rooms previously had musty, humid smells before the renovation.
Sleepability™
8STIL
0-4LUID
4-7.5GEMATIGD
7.5-10STIL
- Slamming doors in the historic hallways
- Occasional noise from the family pool area if your room overlooks it
Voordat je boekt
Goed om te weten
- Guests get reciprocal access to amenities at sister property The Reach (a 5-minute walk away).
- The $60 daily resort fee covers Wi-Fi, poolside popsicles, and beach chairs.
- It's about a 10-15 minute walk to the quieter end of Duval Street.
Wat je mee moet nemen
- Water shoes (the beach can be rocky and has seaweed)
- A portable sound machine (to drown out hallway noise in older buildings)
- Resort wear (the vibe is very 'Lilly Pulitzer chic')
Kamer Genie
Beste keuzes
- Oceanfront Lanai Suites (direct walk-out beach access and private patios)
- Ocean View King with Balcony (great views of the Atlantic)
Kamers om te vermijden
- Base 'Key West View' or 'City View' rooms (often face an alley or parking lot)
- Rooms in the older 1970s wing (feels less luxurious than the historic main building)
Kamer Aanvraag Genie – kopiëren en plakken
“I would love to request a renovated Oceanfront Lanai room or a room in the historic main building, away from the elevators. Please avoid placing us in a 'City View' room facing the alleyway.”
Veelgestelde vragen & Verborgen tips
Alles wat je eigenlijk wilt weten voordat je boekt.
Is the beach actually swimmable?
Yes, but manage your expectations. It's the largest private beach in Key West, but it's often plagued by seaweed and shallow, rocky water. It's better for lounging than swimming.
How far is it from Duval Street?
It's about a 10-15 minute walk to the southern (quieter) end of Duval Street. If you want to go to Mallory Square or the main bars, you'll likely want to bike or take an Uber.
Are the renovations finished?
Yes, the massive property-wide renovation was largely completed in early 2024, bringing updated rooms, a refreshed lobby, and new dining concepts.
Is the resort fee worth it?
It's mandatory ($60/night), so you don't have a choice. It includes Wi-Fi, beach chairs, poolside popsicles, and access to the fitness center and sister property The Reach.
Can I park for free?
No. Self-parking is $45/night and valet is $50/night. Street parking nearby is very limited.
Is it kid-friendly?
Very. There is a dedicated family pool, beach games like cornhole, and the shallow beach water is actually great for toddlers.
Tips van Insiders
- ✨
Walk 5 minutes down the beach to sister property The Reach—you can use their pool and smaller, quieter beach for free.
- ✨
Book the last jet ski tour of the day (around 6 PM) with on-site Barefoot Billy's to catch the sunset from the water.
- ✨
Skip the expensive hotel breakfast and walk or bike to a local spot like Cuban Coffee Queen or Blue Heaven.
5 dingen die je moet weten voordat je gaat
💡The 'City View' rooms are basically 'Alleyway View' rooms.
💡The beach sand is imported and the water is often full of seagrass—don't expect a pristine Caribbean beach.
💡The hotel was originally built in 1920 by railroad tycoon Henry Flagler.
💡You can order room service and take it to the rooftop of sister property The Reach for a private dinner view.
💡Housekeeping can be hit-or-miss; some guests report having to ask multiple times for room cleaning or fresh towels.
Lokaal Playbook
Kaart
Bekijk waar Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton zich bevindt en wat er in de buurt is.