The hype
Travelers love the location and the pool vibe but consistently flag the noise levels and wear-and-tear in the rooms.
CODA Williamsburg
$180-350/ night
Book this if You want a Bali-style pool party in the middle of Brooklyn and plan to be out (or up) late.
Why People Love It
- NYC's largest outdoor heated pool (adults only 21+)
- Prime Williamsburg location right on McCarren Park
- New Michelin-starred chef concept 'Meili' brings serious culinary cred
Quick Take: It’s a pool club with bedrooms attached, so bring earplugs and don't expect a quiet retreat.
Reviewed by @thezaisers: I spent the weekend at CODA and honestly, the pool deck is a game changer for NYC summers. Waking up to that sunlight with coffee in bed was the perfect reset. It’s got such a cool, retro vibe right in the heart of Williamsburg.
Guest Who Stayed Here Said
Reality check
You might get a 'complimentary' daybed, or you might find them all taken by noon — the 'pool access' doesn't guarantee a seat.
- You're here to party and the pool is your #1 priority
- You want to be steps away from Williamsburg's best nightlife
- You appreciate a high-energy, social atmosphere over silence
Cleanliness & Maintenance
7
- Housekeeping: Daily service is generally good, but missed spots and dust are occasionally reported.
- Bathroom hygiene: Mostly clean, but watch out for slow drains and worn grout in older rooms.
- Maintenance: Showing its age. Reports of peeling paint, scuffed furniture, and 'worn' varnish are common.
- Linens & towels: Standard hotel quality, usually fresh but nothing ultra-luxe.
- Odors & scents: Generally fresh, though some hallways can smell of cleaning products or 'party' aftermath.
Sleepability™
5.5MODERATE
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
- Rooftop bar bass (Meili Rooftop)
- Hallway noise/slamming doors
- Street traffic from McCarren Park area
Before you book
Good to know
- The pool is seasonal (May-Sept) and strictly 21+.
- A daily facility fee (~$45.90) is added to your bill.
- Check-in is at 4 PM, which is later than the standard 3 PM.
What to pack
- High-quality earplugs (non-negotiable)
- Swimwear (obviously)
- A portable steamer (irons are available but sometimes hard to get)
Room Genie
Best picks
- Superior Queen with Balcony (park views, outdoor space)
- Penthouse (if you have the budget, for the private patio)
Rooms to avoid
- Lower floor rooms facing the street (noise)
- Rooms near the elevator (hallway noise is a common complaint)
Room Request Genie – copy & paste
“I'd love a room on a higher floor facing McCarren Park for the view, and as far from the elevator as possible to minimize hallway noise.”
FAQ & Hidden tips
Everything you actually want to know before you book.
Is the pool free for guests?
Yes, access is included, but daybeds are first-come, first-served. To guarantee a spot, you have to pay a reservation fee.
Is there parking?
No on-site parking. You'll need to find street parking or use a nearby garage like iPark or Propark ($25-$45/day).
Is breakfast included?
No. There is a coffee station in the morning, but full breakfast is a la carte at the restaurant.
Can I bring my dog?
Yes, it's pet-friendly with a $100 fee per stay (limit 1 dog up to 35lbs).
Is the hotel kid-friendly?
Not really. The pool is 21+ only, and the vibe is very adult-centric/nightlife-focused.
How bad is the noise?
It's a frequent complaint. If you are sensitive to bass or street sounds, request a high floor or look elsewhere.
Insider Tips
- ✨
The 'complimentary' coffee in the lobby runs out fast—get there before 9 AM.
- ✨
You can order food/drinks to the pool, but service can be slow on weekends.
- ✨
The rooftop bar (Meili) has amazing views; go for sunset even if you aren't drinking.
5 things to know before you go
💡The 'resort fee' covers gym access you might not use.
💡Some rooms have 'peek-a-boo' showers that lack total privacy.
💡The elevators can be slow during peak check-out times.
💡You might spot a celebrity (or influencer) in the lobby.
💡The fire alarm has a history of being 'sensitive' (false alarms mentioned in reviews).
Local Playbook
Map
See where CODA Williamsburg is located and what's nearby.