The hype
Families and dog owners love the laid-back atmosphere and beach access, but couples seeking silence often leave frustrated.
Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection By Hilton
$350-800+/ night
Book this if You want a full-service Florida Keys resort experience where you don't have to leave the property to find a beach, a boat, or a decent taco.
Why People Love It
- Two rare sandy beaches (a luxury in the rocky Keys)
- Extremely pet-friendly policy that welcomes dogs of all sizes
- The daily champagne sunset toast is a legitimate vibe
Quick Take: A lush, activity-packed playground that charges luxury prices for a 4-star experience with thin walls.
Reviewed by @ettevi_wanderlust: I spent the most relaxing weekend at Baker's Cay. From biking around the lush property to just floating in the ocean hammocks, it was the perfect reset. The water is crystal clear and the vibe is totally laid-back luxury. Highly recommend for a couple's trip.
Guest Who Stayed Here Said
Reality check
The 'luxury' price tag doesn't always match the room condition—expect some scuffed furniture, peeling paint, and missed housekeeping spots.
- You are traveling with active kids who need constant entertainment
- You are bringing a dog (or two) and want them treated like royalty
- You prioritize sunset views and beach access over absolute silence
Cleanliness & Maintenance
7.8
- Housekeeping: Generally responsive, but reviews frequently mention missed details like dust under beds or forgotten balcony cleaning.
- Bathroom hygiene: Usually good, though humidity in the Keys leads to occasional complaints of mildew in grout or musty smells.
- Maintenance: Shows signs of high traffic—scuffed baseboards, peeling paint on doors, and worn carpet in hallways are common.
- Linens & towels: Standard Hilton quality—clean and crisp, but check for wear and tear (some reports of frayed edges).
- Odors & scents: Lobby smells fresh (signature scent), but rooms can have a lingering damp/musty odor due to the climate.
Sleepability™
6MODERATE
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
- Thin walls (voices/TVs from neighbors)
- Hallway traffic and slamming doors
- Live music from Dry Rocks (if in Coconut Wing)
Before you book
Good to know
- The resort went valet-only for parking in late 2025.
- Beach towels are dispensed via a machine; return them promptly to avoid a charge.
- There are two beaches: Coconut Beach (activity hub) and Hammock Beach (adult-centric/quieter).
What to pack
- Insulated water bottle (refill stations are everywhere and plastic is discouraged)
- Water shoes (the 'sandy' beach still has rocky patches in the water)
- White noise machine (to drown out the hallway traffic)
Room Genie
Best picks
- Coconut Wing, Top Floor Waterfront (best unobstructed ocean views)
- Hammock Wing (for slightly more quiet, though views are tree-obstructed)
Rooms to avoid
- Rooms overlooking the parking lot (road noise from Overseas Hwy)
- Lower floor Coconut Wing rooms near the bar (music noise)
Room Request Genie – copy & paste
“I would love a room on the highest possible floor in the Coconut Wing for the best view. If that is unavailable, I prioritize a quiet room in the Hammock Wing away from the elevators.”
FAQ & Hidden tips
Everything you actually want to know before you book.
Is the beach actually sandy?
Yes, which is rare for Key Largo. It's man-made but soft, though the water entry can be a bit rocky.
Can I park my own car?
No. The resort transitioned to a mandatory valet-only policy (~$35-45/night).
Is breakfast included?
No, unless you have Hilton Honors Gold/Diamond status (and even then, it's a credit). Expect to pay $20-30 per person at Calusa.
How bad is the noise?
It's a consistent complaint. The walls are thin. If you are sensitive to noise, request a top-floor corner room in the Hammock Wing.
Is it worth the resort fee?
Debatable. It covers bikes, paddleboards, kayaks, and fishing rods. If you use those daily, yes. If you just sit by the pool, no.
Are the pools heated?
Yes, both the family pool and the adult waterfall pool are heated.
Insider Tips
- ✨
The 'Champagne Sunset Toast' is free and happens daily—don't miss it.
- ✨
Walk to the far end of Hammock Beach for the most privacy; most guests cluster near the Coconut Wing.
- ✨
The 'resort charge' includes fishing poles and bait—ask at the dock, it's a fun free activity for kids.
5 things to know before you go
💡The 'adults-only' area isn't strictly policed; kids often wander through.
💡You can spot manatees right off the dock if you go early in the morning.
💡The towel machine is aggressive—if you don't scan your band to return them, you WILL get billed.
💡Room service adds a hefty service charge + delivery fee; picking up food yourself saves ~$15.
💡The 'eco-friendly' motion sensor AC thermostats can shut off while you sleep, letting the room get stuffy.
Local Playbook
Map
See where Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection By Hilton is located and what's nearby.