The hype
Travelers are obsessed with the location and room size but frustrated by the lack of standard hotel services.
Hilton Club West 57Th Street New York
$350-550/ night
Book this if You want a spacious, residential-style apartment on Billionaire's Row without the chaos of a tourist-trap hotel lobby.
Why People Love It
- Floor-to-ceiling windows with rare Midtown views
- Dead-silent rooms compared to the rest of the city
- Location directly next to Carnegie Hall and 2 blocks from Central Park
Quick Take: It’s a high-end timeshare masquerading as a hotel, which means huge rooms but zero room service and a painful 10 AM checkout.
Reviewed by @MarieAguirre-Bunch3961720: I stayed at the Hilton Club West 57th and was blown away by the vibe. Waking up to floor-to-ceiling city views was unreal, and the suite felt huge for NYC. My favorite part was definitely the deep soaking tub—it made for the perfect relaxing night in.
Guest Who Stayed Here Said
Reality check
You will likely be denied access to the lounge and breakfast even if you have Hilton Honors status.
- You need a separate living area or kitchenette
- You prioritize sleep and silence over a lobby scene
- You are attending a show at Carnegie Hall next door
Cleanliness & Maintenance
9
- Housekeeping: Excellent when provided, but verify if your rate includes daily service.
- Bathroom hygiene: Immaculate. Modern grout, clean glass showers, no mold reports.
- Maintenance: High standard. Furniture is sturdy and well-kept; minimal wear and tear.
- Linens & towels: Crisp, high-quality Hilton linens. Towels are fluffy and plentiful.
- Odors & scents: Neutral and fresh. No signature scent, but no mustiness either.
Sleepability™
8.5SILENT
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
- Street noise on floors 1-10
- Elevator dings if room is near the lift bank
Before you book
Good to know
- This is a Hilton Grand Vacations property, so the front desk operates more like a condo concierge.
- Luggage storage is available if you want to explore after the early checkout.
- There is a 'short stay fee' of ~$85 for some bookings under 3 nights—check your fine print.
What to pack
- Ground coffee (rooms have coffee makers but pods/supplies can be stingy)
- Eye mask (the floor-to-ceiling windows are bright in the morning)
- Your own snacks (no minibar or room service)
Room Genie
Best picks
- Penthouse Suites (Floors 25-26) for private balconies
- High-floor (20+) Premier Studios for Central Park glimpses
Rooms to avoid
- Low-floor rooms facing 57th Street (siren noise)
- Rooms directly next to the elevator bank
Room Request Genie – copy & paste
“I am requesting a high-floor room (20+) away from the elevators. If available, a unit with a view of Central Park would be appreciated.”
FAQ & Hidden tips
Everything you actually want to know before you book.
Is there a pool?
No, there is no pool on-site.
Do I get free breakfast?
No. The lounge with breakfast is for owners only. There is no restaurant on-site.
What is the checkout time?
10:00 AM sharp. Late checkout is rarely granted due to cleaning schedules.
Is there daily housekeeping?
It depends on how you booked. Cash rates usually include it; points/exchange bookings often charge a fee.
Can I park my car there?
Valet only (~$70/day). No in/out privileges. Large SUVs pay extra.
Is it pet friendly?
No, pets are not allowed (service animals only).
Insider Tips
- ✨
The 'Owners Lounge' on the mezzanine is sometimes accessible if you just walk in with confidence, but don't count on it.
- ✨
There is a Duane Reade pharmacy right around the corner for stocking your fridge.
- ✨
Avoid the valet: use the SpotHero app to find a garage on 56th or 58th St for half the price.
5 things to know before you go
💡The elevators can be slow during the 9:30 AM checkout rush.
💡The 'kitchenette' in studios is often just a mini-fridge and microwave, not a full kitchen.
💡You are sleeping on top of a Taco Bell (located in the retail space below/nearby).
💡The lobby is tiny and often crowded with luggage.
💡You have to pay for housekeeping if you book via RCI or certain timeshare exchanges.
Local Playbook
Map
See where Hilton Club West 57Th Street New York is located and what's nearby.