The hype
Great location for getting around, but the property feels neglected and the amenities are a mirage.
Sheraton Brooklyn New York
$150-300/ night
Book this if You need a functional, transit-rich base in Downtown Brooklyn and plan to spend zero time in the hotel.
Why People Love It
- Subway nirvana: A, C, F, R, 2, 3 trains are practically downstairs
- Walkable to Barclays Center and DeKalb Market Hall
- Cheaper than Manhattan but only 15 minutes away
Quick Take: A tired corporate sleeper that rents out its own pool to a swim school so you can't use it.
Reviewed by @willianaashley: I booked a solo weekend here just to recharge and honestly, it was perfect. Seeing my name on the TV and watching the rain fall over Brooklyn from that huge window felt like such a main character moment. The bed is super plush too.
Guest Who Stayed Here Said
Reality check
Guests are consistently furious about the 'indoor pool' listed on third-party sites being inaccessible.
- You are attending an event at Barclays Center
- You prioritize subway access over room comfort
- You just need a bed and a shower for a business trip
Cleanliness & Maintenance
5
- Housekeeping: Inconsistent. Many reports of missed trash and 'light' cleaning only.
- Bathroom hygiene: Grout often looks tired; check drains for hair. Not 'sparkling'.
- Maintenance: Peeling wallpaper and scuffed furniture are common complaints.
- Linens & towels: Standard industrial quality, but check for stains immediately.
- Odors & scents: Hallways can smell musty or like 'old carpet'.
Sleepability™
5MODERATE
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
- Street noise (sirens, traffic)
- Loud in-room HVAC units
- Hallway noise through thin doors
Before you book
Good to know
- The 'Kimoto' rooftop bar is a separate venue; guests don't get special priority
- No self-parking on site; valet is pricey ($50-75+)
- Destination fee of ~$25/night is charged but offers little value
What to pack
- Earplugs or white noise machine
- Slippers (carpets are worn)
- Your own toiletries (hotel supply is often stingy)
Room Genie
Best picks
- High-floor rooms (20+) facing away from Duffield St for slightly less noise
- Corner rooms for a bit more space and light
Rooms to avoid
- Rooms near the elevator (constant dinging)
- Lower floors (street noise is intense)
- Connecting rooms (sound leakage is worse)
Room Request Genie – copy & paste
“I am a light sleeper and requesting a high-floor room (20th floor or higher) away from the elevators. Please ensure the room does not have a connecting door.”
FAQ & Hidden tips
Everything you actually want to know before you book.
Is the pool actually open for guests?
Practically, no. It is rented to 'Take Me To The Water' swim school. Guests rarely, if ever, get access.
Does the hotel have a free breakfast?
No. Breakfast is a la carte at Avere Ristorante and costs ~$20-30 per person.
Is there a Club Lounge?
Yes, but reviews describe it as sad—often just coffee, water, and pretzels, with no real food service.
How much is parking?
Valet is steep (often quoted $60-75). Use a parking app to find a garage on Bridge St for ~$30/day.
Is it safe at night?
Generally yes, Downtown Brooklyn is busy, but Duffield St can feel a bit gritty late at night. Stick to main avenues.
Can I bring my dog?
Yes, it is pet-friendly, but expect a non-refundable pet fee (around $150).
Insider Tips
- ✨
Skip the hotel breakfast; 'Junior's' is a short walk for legendary cheesecake and breakfast.
- ✨
The 'A' train at Jay St-MetroTech gets you to JFK Airport relatively easily.
- ✨
Check the AC unit immediately; if it rattles, ask to move rooms before unpacking.
5 things to know before you go
💡The 'Rooftop Garden' is actually a loud nightlife spot, not a zen hotel amenity.
💡Elevators can be painfully slow during morning rush hour.
💡The 'destination fee' is mandatory even if you don't use the wifi or gym.
💡Housekeeping is often 'by request only' despite what the website says.
💡The lobby Starbucks has weird hours and isn't always reliable.
Local Playbook
Map
See where Sheraton Brooklyn New York is located and what's nearby.