The hype
Great location and friendly staff, but the rooms are tiny and showing their age.
Aloft New York Brooklyn
$150-250/ night
Book this if You want a relatively affordable, subway-connected crash pad in Downtown Brooklyn and plan to be out (or partying) until 2am.
Why People Love It
- Incredible subway access (Hoyt St & Jay St-MetroTech)
- W XYZ Bar has a genuine social scene
- Cheaper than Manhattan but only 15 mins away
Quick Take: A loud, energetic dormitory for adults that trades sleep quality for location and vibes.
Reviewed by @_empressmelanin: I stayed here for a quick Brooklyn trip and was shocked to find an indoor pool—such a rare perk! The room was cozy but super modern, and I loved hanging out on the terrace with my morning coffee. Definitely my go-to for a fun, high-energy stay near City Point.
Guest Who Stayed Here Said
Reality check
The 'party hotel' reputation is real—expect noise from the rooftop bar and street traffic to bleed into your room.
- You're under 35 and value nightlife over silence
- You need to be at Barclays Center or MetroTech in minutes
- You travel with a dog (very pet-friendly)
Cleanliness & Maintenance
7.8
- Housekeeping: Inconsistent. Many guests report missed days or having to beg for fresh towels.
- Bathroom hygiene: Generally okay, but grout lines in showers often show age and pink mold.
- Maintenance: High traffic means wear and tear: scuffed walls, chipped furniture, and loose handles are common.
- Linens & towels: Standard Marriott quality—clean but not luxurious. Check for stains upon arrival.
- Odors & scents: Lobby smells like the signature Aloft perfume; hallways can smell like weed or damp carpet.
Sleepability™
6MODERATE
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
- Kimoto Rooftop Bar (bass on upper floors)
- Thin hallway walls
- Street noise (sirens/traffic) on lower floors
Before you book
Good to know
- The pool is in the Sheraton building next door (connected)
- Destination fee of ~$30/night is added at check-in
- No microwave in standard rooms
What to pack
- High-quality earplugs (non-negotiable)
- Flip flops for the pool/hallway
- HDMI cable (TVs have ports but streaming casting is hit-or-miss)
Room Genie
Best picks
- Middle floors (10-15) facing away from Duffield St for the best balance of view vs. noise
- Corner rooms for slightly more square footage
Rooms to avoid
- Top floors (near the rooftop bar noise)
- Lower floors (street noise)
- Rooms near the elevator (thin walls amplify hallway chatter)
Room Request Genie – copy & paste
“I am a light sleeper. Please assign a room on a middle floor (10-15), away from the elevator and facing the quietest possible side, to minimize rooftop bass and street noise.”
FAQ & Hidden tips
Everything you actually want to know before you book.
Is the pool actually in the hotel?
Sort of. It's in the adjacent Sheraton. You have access, but it requires walking through a connector and keycards sometimes fail.
How bad is the noise?
Bad. It consistently ranks on 'noisiest hotels in NYC' lists due to the rooftop club. If you sleep light, look elsewhere.
Is there free breakfast?
No. There's a 'Re:fuel' grab-and-go pantry with paid egg sandwiches and coffee. Better options are a 2-minute walk away.
Can I bring my dog?
Yes, Aloft is very dog-friendly. $50/night fee + $100 deposit applies.
How far is the subway?
Incredibly close. Hoyt St (2/3 trains) is 2 minutes away; Jay St-MetroTech (A/C/F/R) is 5 minutes.
Is the neighborhood safe?
Yes, Downtown Brooklyn is busy and safe, though it gets quiet/desolate late at night. Standard city awareness applies.
Insider Tips
- ✨
Walk to 'Little Pizza Parlor' on Duffield for a late-night slice—it's better than the hotel snacks.
- ✨
The Sheraton next door has a full restaurant if you don't want to leave the complex but need real food.
- ✨
Use the 'Mobile Key' in the Marriott app to bypass the often-crowded front desk.
5 things to know before you go
💡The 'Rooftop Bar' isn't just a hotel bar; it's a third-party nightlife venue (Kimoto) that draws a non-guest crowd.
💡The elevators can be agonizingly slow during morning rush and Friday evenings.
💡The 'City View' rooms often just look at the side of another building unless you're very high up.
💡Housekeeping is sometimes 'on request' only—verify this at check-in if you want daily service.
💡The HVAC units are motion-activated in some rooms, meaning the AC might turn off while you sleep.
Local Playbook
Map
See where Aloft New York Brooklyn is located and what's nearby.