The hype
Families and couples love the beach access and pool, but often feel the rooms are dated for the price point.
The Surf Club
$320-600+/ night
Book this if You want the classic Montauk experience—right on the ocean, family-friendly, and blissfully removed from the chaotic party scene.
Why People Love It
- Direct, private access to a stunning stretch of beach with chair service
- Condo-style units with full kitchens make longer stays easy
- Heated outdoor pool that's actually large enough for swimming
Quick Take: It’s a glorified, well-located condo complex that costs a fortune in summer, but the oceanfront location is arguably worth the premium.
Reviewed by @amandasparkles: I stayed in this duplex right on the dunes and the separation between the living area and bedroom made it feel huge. The skylight was my favorite feature for stargazing, and walking straight onto the beach from the deck made the whole trip effortless.
Guest Who Stayed Here Said
Reality check
The 'resort fee' feels steep when there's no daily housekeeping for some rentals and no food service, but the beach chair setup saves the day.
- You prioritize being 50 steps from the ocean over having a lobby bar
- You are traveling with kids and need a kitchen/living room setup
- You want to be walking distance to town but sleep in silence
Cleanliness & Maintenance
8.3
- Housekeeping: Daily housekeeping is generally provided, but some guests report missed spots or sand left behind.
- Bathroom hygiene: Generally clean, though some grout and fixtures show age in non-renovated units.
- Maintenance: Grounds are immaculate; room interiors vary—some have peeling paint or worn furniture.
- Linens & towels: Standard hotel quality; beach towels are provided but can run out on busy weekends.
- Odors & scents: Some complaints of 'musty' smells in ground-floor units due to the ocean dampness.
Sleepability™
8.5SILENT
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
- Thin walls between connected duplex units
- Occasional hallway noise from neighbors
Before you book
Good to know
- There is a mandatory resort fee (~$54/night) that covers beach chairs, towels, and parking
- Check-in is late (4:00 PM or 5:00 PM) and they are strict about it
- The property closes for the winter season (Nov-April)
What to pack
- Groceries: The in-room kitchens are empty, so bring coffee, milk, and snacks
- Beach bag: You'll be spending all day on the sand
- Cash: For tips for the beach attendants who set up your chairs
Room Genie
Best picks
- Unit 73 (2-Bedroom Duplex): Known for excellent ocean views and spacious layout
- Upper-floor units: Better views and no footsteps from above
- Oceanfront units: Worth the upgrade over 'Garden View' which just looks at the pool/parking
Rooms to avoid
- Ground floor units near the pool gate if you dislike foot traffic
- Garden view units if you came specifically for the ocean vista
Room Request Genie – copy & paste
“I would love to request an upper-floor unit with a direct ocean view, ideally away from the main pool gate for privacy. If a renovated unit with updated furniture is available, that would be my preference.”
FAQ & Hidden tips
Everything you actually want to know before you book.
Is there a restaurant on site?
No. There are no restaurants or bars on the property, but you are a 5-minute walk to town.
Is it pet friendly?
No. Pets are strictly prohibited at The Surf Club Resort.
Does it have a pool?
Yes, a large heated outdoor pool that is open seasonally.
Is parking included?
Yes, one parking spot is typically included with the resort fee, but space can be tight.
How far is the beach?
It is directly on the beach. You walk over a private boardwalk through the dunes.
Is this the place with the concerts?
No! That is The Surf Lodge. This is The Surf Club. It is quiet here.
Insider Tips
- ✨
Use the 'Book the Beach' service early in the morning to reserve your specific umbrella spot for the day.
- ✨
Look out for the occasional free food truck (tacos/pizza) that the hotel brings in on select summer evenings.
- ✨
There is a steam room in the fitness center building that many guests miss entirely.
5 things to know before you go
💡The 'sofa beds' in the living rooms are notoriously uncomfortable—avoid sleeping on them if possible.
💡There is no elevator, so if you pack heavy and are on the 2nd floor, be prepared to haul.
💡Some units are privately owned and rented out, meaning decor quality varies wildly from 'chic' to '1990s'.
💡The WiFi can be spotty in the units furthest from the main office.
💡You can legally have a bonfire on the beach here (in a metal container), which is a rare magic.
Local Playbook
Map
See where The Surf Club is located and what's nearby.