The hype
Guests are obsessed with the aesthetics, the pool, and the showers, but often sticker-shocked by the food prices.
The Lake House On Canandaigua
$250-550/ night
Book this if You want a design-forward, Hamptons-style lake retreat without the Hamptons crowds (or attitude).
Why People Love It
- Heated lakefront pool and hot tub open year-round
- Scandi-chic interiors that feel like a wealthy friend's summer home
- The Sand Bar is a legitimate local hotspot, not just a hotel trap
Quick Take: A stunning visual masterpiece that sometimes forgets it's a hotel—expect thin walls and steep prices for eggs.
Reviewed by @itskimberlyfisher: I stayed here for a weekend recharge and the design blew me away. The room feels so airy, and sitting on that balcony watching the boats go by was my favorite part. It’s the perfect quiet escape if you love minimalist aesthetics.
Guest Who Stayed Here Said
Reality check
Families love the pool in summer, which can annoy couples seeking a quiet romantic getaway.
- You appreciate high-design minimalism (lots of white oak and natural light)
- You want a pool you can actually swim in during winter
- You are a foodie who cares about farm-to-table sourcing
Cleanliness & Maintenance
9.2
- Housekeeping: Daily service is thorough; guests rarely complain about missed spots.
- Bathroom hygiene: Immaculate. Tile work is pristine and grout is clean.
- Maintenance: The property is new (2020) and well-maintained; everything feels fresh.
- Linens & towels: High-quality, crisp white linens and plush towels.
- Odors & scents: Fresh, woody, and clean—no musty lake smells here.
Sleepability™
6.5MODERATE
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
- Footsteps from guests in rooms above (hardwood floors)
- Hallway noise due to large gaps under doors
Before you book
Good to know
- The hotel is built on the site of a former Sheraton—look for the '1970' nod in the branding.
- Valet parking is included in the resort fee, so use it.
- The 'Sand Bar' is open seasonally; check dates if you're visiting in winter.
What to pack
- Swimsuit (year-round for the heated pool and hot tub)
- White noise machine (essential for lower-floor rooms)
- Yoga clothes for the morning wellness classes
Room Genie
Best picks
- Top-floor Lake View King (Main Building) to avoid overhead noise
- Cottage Suites for more privacy and canal/lake views
Rooms to avoid
- Ground floor rooms in the Main Building (noise from above)
- Rooms facing the parking lot (often sold as 'Town View')
Room Request Genie – copy & paste
“I am a light sleeper and would love a top-floor room in the Main Building to avoid overhead footstep noise. A direct lake view is preferred over the canal view if possible.”
FAQ & Hidden tips
Everything you actually want to know before you book.
Is the pool actually open in winter?
Yes, the pool is heated to ~82°F year-round, and the hot tub is huge.
Is it pet-friendly?
Yes, dogs under 35lbs are welcome in specific cottage rooms for a $75-$100 fee plus cleaning.
Does the room have a coffee maker?
Yes, rooms come with Nespresso machines.
Is breakfast included?
No, and it's pricey. Expect to pay a la carte at Rose Tavern.
How far is the wine trail?
You are right at the top of the Canandaigua Wine Trail; wineries are a 10-20 minute drive.
Is there a gym?
Yes, a well-equipped gym with Peloton bikes.
Insider Tips
- ✨
Ask for a s'mores kit at the front desk to use at the fire pits.
- ✨
The 'Library' bar off the lobby is a cozy, quieter alternative to the main restaurants.
- ✨
If you rent a pool daybed in summer, you might get treated to frozen grapes.
5 things to know before you go
💡The hotel sits on the footprint of a 1970s motor lodge, which explains the exterior layout.
💡You can hear your upstairs neighbor walking around as if they are in the room with you.
💡The 'Town View' rooms basically look at a parking lot.
💡Early check-in can cost upwards of $200 if you want it guaranteed.
💡The showers have incredible pressure, a rare win for hotel plumbing.
Local Playbook
Map
See where The Lake House On Canandaigua is located and what's nearby.