Roomer

Margaritaville Resort Times Square

New York, NY, USA
$230-350/ night

Book this if You want a heated outdoor pool in December and don't mind trading room size for a kitschy, fun atmosphere in the center of the action.

Why People Love It

8.7⭐3008 reviews
  • The only year-round outdoor heated rooftop pool in Times Square
  • Soundproof windows that actually block out the midtown chaos
  • Tropical escapism that feels genuinely fun, not just tacky

Quick Take: It’s a cruise ship docked on 7th Avenue—tiny cabins, expensive drinks, and a surprising amount of fun if you embrace the theme.

Reviewed by @Raptoradventures: I stayed in this turquoise paradise right in Times Square and I'm obsessed. The bathroom lighting is elite for makeup, and waking up to that city skyline view was a core memory. It’s giving total Barbie dreamhouse energy in the middle of NYC. Highly recommend for a girls' trip!

Guest Who Stayed Here Said

The hype

Guests are shocked by how quiet the rooms are given the location, but almost everyone complains about the slow elevators.

Reality check

You are paying for the location and the pool; the room itself is a crash pad, not a suite.

  • You refuse to let winter stop you from swimming
  • You need to be within walking distance of Broadway theaters
  • You appreciate a 'no-judgment' vacation vibe in the middle of a serious city

Cleanliness & Maintenance

8.5
  • Housekeeping: Generally reliable daily service, though high turnover means occasional missed dust.
  • Bathroom hygiene: Clean surfaces, but the shower design causes water pooling issues on the floor.
  • Maintenance: Newer building (opened 2021), so fixtures are still in good shape.
  • Linens & towels: Crisp white linens, usually fresh, though some reports of stingy towel counts.
  • Odors & scents: Lobby smells like a tropical breeze (pumped in scent); rooms are neutral.

Sleepability™

7.5SILENT
SILENT
0-4LOUD
4-7.5MODERATE
7.5-10SILENT
  • Hallway chatter
  • Connecting room doors (avoid if possible)
  • Elevator dings if near the bank

Before you book

Good to know

  • The pool is open year-round and heated, but it's small—get there early.
  • There is a historic synagogue located within the building complex (a unique lease agreement).
  • Valet parking is pricey (~$95/night nearby); use an app like SpotHero to find a garage on a side street for half the price.

What to pack

  • Swimsuit (yes, even in January)
  • Flip flops for the pool deck
  • Earplugs (just in case of noisy hallway neighbors)

Room Genie

Best picks

  • Floors 24-28 for the best city views and less street vibration
  • Corner rooms for dual-aspect windows and slightly more light

Rooms to avoid

  • Rooms ending in '06' or near the elevator bank (high foot traffic)
  • Connecting rooms if you aren't booking both sides (sound bleed)

Room Request Genie – copy & paste

“I would love a room on a high floor (20+) away from the elevators. Please ensure it is NOT a connecting room if possible, as I am a light sleeper. A view of the ball drop/Times Square would be a huge bonus.”

FAQ & Hidden tips

Everything you actually want to know before you book.

Is the pool actually open in winter?

Yes, it is heated and open year-round. It's a major highlight.

How much is the resort fee?

Expect to pay around $57.31 per night, which includes pool access and wifi.

Is breakfast included?

No. Breakfast is available at the restaurant but costs extra ($9-$24 range).

Can I store my bags before check-in?

Yes, the front desk will hold luggage so you can explore Times Square.

Is it loud at night?

Street noise is minimal due to good windows, but internal hallway noise can be an issue.

What is the check-out time?

Check-out is at 12:00 PM (noon), which is generous for NYC.

Insider Tips

  • ✨

    Ask to be seated near the Statue of Liberty in the restaurant; she 'toasts' with her margarita glass every 30 minutes.

  • ✨

    The '5 o'Clock Somewhere' bar on the 31st floor has better views than the pool deck.

  • ✨

    Skip the hotel coffee; there's a much better cafe just a block away in Hell's Kitchen.

5 things to know before you go

  • 💡The shower glass is often only a half-panel, meaning water sprays all over the bathroom floor.

  • 💡There is an active synagogue located inside the building's footprint.

  • 💡The elevators can be a bottleneck, especially around 11 AM - 12 PM check-out.

  • 💡You can't bring outside food or drink to the pool deck (they check bags).

  • 💡The 'LandShark' bar has a different, more casual vibe than the rooftop if you want a quicker drink.

Local Playbook

Map

See where Margaritaville Resort Times Square is located and what's nearby.

Key amenities & services