The hype
Guests love the location and the rooftop pool views, but the rooms feel worn and the elevators are a test of patience.
Royalton Park Avenue
$230-450/ notte
Prenota se You want a rooftop pool scene in NoMad and don't mind sacrificing some sleep for the 'see-and-be-seen' vibe.
Perché piace così tanto
- Heated indoor/outdoor rooftop pool open year-round (a Manhattan unicorn)
- Location is dead-center NoMad, walkable to everything from Eataly to the Empire State Building
- The Ivy Room and rooftop bar draw a genuine local crowd, not just tourists
In sintesi: A former 'it' hotel that's still riding the coattails of its Gansevoort glory days, with a killer rooftop but tired rooms that desperately need a refresh.
Recensito da @_briiiana: I stayed here for a weekend getaway and the rooftop pool completely stole the show. Waking up to that Empire State Building view made me feel like a total VIP. It’s the perfect spot if you want that trendy NYC energy without the chaos.
Cosa hanno detto gli ospiti che hanno soggiornato qui
Reality check
The 'Superior' rooms are shockingly small compared to the wide-angle website photos, and you might find peeling wallpaper or missed cleaning spots.
- You prioritize a year-round heated pool over a quiet night's sleep
- You want to be in the middle of the NoMad restaurant scene
- You're traveling with a dog (very pet-friendly, though for a fee)
Pulizia e manutenzione
6
- Housekeeping: Inconsistent. Some guests rave, others find dust bunnies and missed items from previous guests.
- Bathroom hygiene: Concerning reports of black mold in grout and tubs that need a good scrub.
- Maintenance: Aging infrastructure. Peeling wallpaper, chipped furniture, and loud AC units are common complaints.
- Linens & towels: Generally decent, 400-thread count Egyptian cotton, but watch for wear and tear.
- Odors & scents: Usually fine, though some hallways can smell musty or like old cleaning products.
Sleepability™
5MODERATO
0-4RUMOROSO
4-7.5MODERATO
7.5-10SILENZIOSO
- Old, rattling air conditioning units
- Rooftop bar music/bass (affects upper floors)
- Street noise from Park Avenue South
Prima di prenotare
Buono a sapersi
- The rooftop pool is for guests only, but the deck opens to the public/parties, so it gets crowded.
- Elevators are notoriously slow; factor in an extra 5-10 minutes if you're on a schedule.
- Coffee and tea are complimentary in the lobby from 6-7 AM only (blink and you miss it).
Cosa portare
- Earplugs (non-negotiable for light sleepers)
- Swimsuit (year-round heated pool is the main draw)
- Patience for the elevators
Genio delle camere
Migliori scelte
- Grand Deluxe King (actually spacious, unlike the 'Superior' closets)
- Park Avenue Suite (corner views and Juliet balconies make it feel like a real apartment)
Camere da evitare
- Superior Rooms (cramped, often dark, and feel like a downgrade)
- Rooms near the elevators (noise bleed is real)
- Top floor rooms directly under the pool deck (unless you like sleeping inside a subwoofer)
Genio delle richieste camera – copia e incolla
“I'd love a quiet room away from the elevators and not directly below the rooftop bar. If possible, a room with a Juliet balcony facing 29th Street rather than Park Avenue for less street noise.”
FAQ e consigli nascosti
Tutto ciò che vuoi davvero sapere prima di prenotare.
Is the pool actually open in winter?
Yes, it's heated and has an indoor/outdoor setup, so you can swim year-round.
Does the hotel have room service?
Yes, 24-hour room service is available (a rarity these days).
Is it pet friendly?
Yes, dogs are welcome for a fee (approx. $100-$125 per stay), and they even have water bowls available.
How much is the resort fee?
Expect to pay around $55 per night, which covers wifi and gym access.
Can I park my car there?
Only if you're rich. Valet is ~$85/night. Use a parking app to find a garage nearby for half the price.
Are the rooms renovated?
It's a mixed bag. Some are refreshed, but many guests report 'tired' furniture, peeling wallpaper, and worn carpets.
Suggerimenti degli Insider
- ✨
Ask for a room with a Juliet balcony; even if you can't step out, the floor-to-ceiling air is a game changer.
- ✨
The 'facility fee' includes Citi Bike passes—ask the front desk for them or you're wasting money.
- ✨
The lobby fireplace is a legitimate vibe for a drink if the rooftop is too chaotic.
5 cose da sapere prima di partire
💡The 'Superior' rooms are so small you might trip over your suitcase.
💡Housekeeping can be hit-or-miss; check behind the couch (one guest found a stranger's jacket and underwear there).
💡The shower pressure in some rooms is described as 'less than energizing'.
💡You can hear your neighbors in the hallway due to thin doors.
💡The 'Alice in Wonderland' lobby decor is fun but feels a bit like 2010 called and wants its furniture back.
Guida locale
Mappa
Scopri dove si trova Royalton Park Avenue e cosa c'è nelle vicinanze.